Monday, February 9, 2026

Monday Evening Sentimonies: Free Agency

Free agency official opens tomorrow. Which means that we get to confirm all the things that were leaked out during legal tampering. Which is really just all the things that were sorted out during illegal tampering… which totally does not happen (wink, wink). 

We already know the Riders’ roster is taking some hits. Starters like Reavis, Allen and Carney as well as depth guys like Maeir, Baldonado, Nield and Robustelli are all gone. To compensate we will be adding James Vaughters, James Letcher (a very dangerous returner) and Josh Woods (veteran depth at LB). 

So what does this all mean for the Riders?

Well before people start their annual freak out that O’Day does nothing remember a) the most active teams in free agency are the crappiest teams and b) O’Day has already successfully extended 22 of our pending free agents. He put in the bulk of his work before free agency in trying to keep together as much of the core as possible. This includes top end talent like Emilus, Campbell and Johnson. So yes losing guys like Carney, Allen and Reavis sucks but its not end of the world. O’Day has done a great job of building depth. The development of guys like Brooks and Miller are factors in letting Allen and Reavis go.

Defensive end still concerns me at this point. Vaughters helps but he is 5-6 sack a year guy. Great for the rotation but not the guy. Him and Korte-Moore are currently our most decorated ends. If the Riders signed me I would be tied for 3rd most CFL sacks by a defensive end. We have brought in a ton of new recruits and obviously hope one or 2 pan out but its far from a guarantee. But other than that I don’t see us as having major holes in the roster. Depth is a concern … but we also went from ridiculous depth to not as much so the level of concern is relative.

The biggest news was a release, not a signing. The Brett Lauther era is over. It will go down as a storied career of someone who was great on and off the field. But football is a cruel sport and as so often happens, rather than a heroes send off he gets unceremoniously dumped. Dumped for very good reasons but dumped nonetheless. To me the most shocking thing is not that we cut ties… its that we cut ties after sticking with him so long. If we still believed in him at the end of last season then I did not see us moving on now. I have nothing but respect for Lauther. From his humble beginnings of 18 years spent on practice rosters before getting his shot to even on his worst days never shying away from holding himself accountable in the media. His integrity and perseverance are commendable.  

We appear to be going American as we have now signed 2 American kickers. Be interesting to see how that plays out. You may say it can’t get worse than Lauther was last season, but to you I say… Campbell Fair. So forgive my concern. 

I am still holding out hope that we can keep CJ Avery. But I guess we will see how it goes.


3 comments:

Ethan said...

Here’s my concerns.

- You don’t lose Carney, Allen, Reavis, as well as Baldonaldo, Robustelli & Nield, the latter 2 being the 4th guy on West rivals, & be better. And there are questions @ kicker like it or not.
- BC had 1 less win & lost one guy of note.
- Wpg lost no one of note
- Edm brings back 11 of 12 starters on defence that allowed the fewest points in the league after that 1-6 start - the one new player is Carney. And on offence added 2 solid receivers & a trio of veteran OL.
Neither of those teams is in a rebuild. Both are improved. The Stamps are the only team outside of the Riders who have suffered significant losses.
The past two years I had the Riders finishing 1st - clear Cup favourites in 2025. The bookies will have them there this season, as they had the Bombers last year. IMO they will be hard pressed to repeat. Fingers crossed.



Rider Prophet said...

No, I would defintely not argue we are better. But I still think we are good enough to compete.
BC lost a tackle and receiver but gained Sankey.
Winnipeg made some nice additions (Ceresna, White, Broxton) but the core of their team (Collaros, Demski, Neufeld, Bryant, Willie are old). Not sure they have done enough to reverse their decline.
Edmonton should take a step forward with a full yera of Fajardo.
Calgary is a bit like us, some loses but still a good team.
We should not be the favourites at this point but lots can happen over 18 games to change things.

Ethan said...

Absolutely agree that the Riders are good enough to compete. I still see them as 2nd because BC has Rourke & a dominant offence. On DL with Betts on the edge, Tavai & Sayles & then Sankey @ MLB they have us outdone there - sacks (1st), TFL (3rd), FF (2nd). As good as it gets for pressuring QB's.

The achilles heel? IF Rourke gets hurt, they're done. But you could say the same for the Riders or a # of other clubs. For sure the West is going to be super competitive, unlike the East where the Als should be home & free IMO.