Monday, November 16, 2026

Monday Morning Sentimonies: 2026 Post Mortem

The green and gold confetti (yet again soaked in the tears of the Alouettes) has fallen and the 2026 season has come to a close. With it we say goodbye to the 55 yard line, a coherent playoff format and passes doinking off the post. I won’t lie, I was kinda hoping Fajardo would doink one in the Grey Cup for old time sake. 

Now obviously we had all hoped that a team in a different shade of green was standing on that podium last night. But it was not to be. So before we formally turn our attention to 2027 (and a home Grey Cup), let’s take one last look at what went wrong in 2026 and the factors that led to us watching the last 2 rounds of the postseason from the sidelines. 

There are lots of things you could point to that led to the Riders not being able to repeat. Big outward migration of talent following the 2025 season, other teams in the West caught up, that trick roper only being booked for one half time, large scale anti-Rider reffing conspiracies. The list goes on and on. But I think I would distill it down to three major things. 

#3 – Injuries

All teams deal with them so they are certainly not an excuse but there’s no denying injuries played a factor in the Riders season. Our best defensive player did not play 8 quarters of football. All our top receivers (and even our not-so top one) were injured at some point. One week we were so injury depleted that we had to dress a 7th O-linemen solely because that was the only remaining healthy Canadian we had avaialble. Oddly enough about the only thing that avoided injury was our senior citizen QB. If the Riders offense had stayed healthy all year I think 1-2 more wins would have been realistic and that could have meant 2nd place and a home playoff game. I do not think it would have changed the outcome of the playoff game because the offense was healthy and still not good enough. But much like in the ’08 and ‘14 season, injuries played a major impact in us falling short of a repeat. 

#2 - Roster gambles not paying off

I will say this without any hesitation, I like O’Day and think he is good at his job. But he made some calculated gambles in assembling the 2026 roster that just did not pan out. He gambled on special teams investing a big name returner. Letcher could have been a dangerous weapon but almost logged more games missed due to injury than actual kicks returned. He gambled when we let Jonathan Kim (the unquestioned best kicker we had in camp) walk and rolled the dice on Hale rather than replace a backup American on defense with a global player (who by the way we had in camp, Vrede). The biggest gamble was spending big on offense and assuming we could recruit and develop on defense rather than spending big there. Had the offense stayed healthy it could have worked but if you watched the back half of our season it was clear that we did not have the horses on defense (particularly with Milligan out). O’Day took some chances and a lot of them just didn’t pay off. 

And that brings us to the #1 thing on the list.

1. Defensive End

This should come as no surprise as it was the biggest question mark on the team coming into the season. We had no defensive end. We let Carney walk and rather than spend to bring in a top end replacement we assumed that if we invited 100 new recruits to camp 1 or 2 would surely pan out. We did find a couple decent DE’s. I like Roberson a lot. I think Evans is decent. But at this point in their career, neither were game wreckers. Last year we had guys like Carney and Micah would could disrupt a play by themselves. So when we put a bunch a decent pass rushers around them the whole system works. We get pressure and most importantly the secondary is not left out to dry. This year we had a bunch of good pass rushers but no great ones. And boy oh boy did it very quickly expose how not good our secondary was. I think even a great secondary would struggle if you don’t have disruptive forces up front and our secondary this year was about as close to great as Ryan Dinwiddie was to the Grey Cup. 

A lack of a top end DE was for me the biggest issue plaguing this team in 2026.

And with that we are moving on to 2027… after the 2026 Rider Prophet Awards of course, coming next week.

2 comments:

Ethan said...

Looking Back
In June I felt a deja vu feeling & commented here I was very wary of the Elks. Losing half the GC depth chart to FA reminded me of 2013. Now Hervey's team in year 2 has risen to the top with a slew of young talent. Familiar feelings.

Looking Ahead to the West 2027
The Elk roster at this time - 72 players, FOUR over 30, most of the young defence signed for 2027. They're not going anywhere.
The Lions are set to move on from some older players on both sides of the ball. But the core & Rourke will be there. The OL needs a rebuild.
The Stamps were the 2nd youngest team & have a lot of raw talent. Great offence, need to tweak the defence. I expect them to be better.
Winnipeg - nothing short of a major rebuild needed. 13 players 33 or older by start of 2027 - 11 of them starters. May end up last if Ottawa gets it together

The Riders? IMHO - they need some catching up to do to finish 3rd. Again we have the highest # of FA's with all teams but Mtl & Edm reporting. The offence should be good. Ouellette has missed 21 games as a Rider & turns 32. Time to move on.
On D, Milligan, Vaughters & Rose are all 34-35 next year. Is there still some upside to Ford, Fields & Lokombo? Not as starters IMO. This side of the ball needs the most attention.
We should be competitive but some hard work ahead of us if we want to move up from 3rd. FA is going to be very critical this year.

Anonymous said...

With the new playoff system in place for next season, finishing atop your division gives you an extra life. The bottom seeds will have a much tougher go of it. With Bo back the East should have 3 very competitive clubs along with 4 in the West.
At this early stage, my guess is the TiCats will join the Elks, Als & Lions as teams with good balance on defence & offence. I would place the Riders in with the Argos & Stamps on a slightly lower tier. All 3 have top end talent on offence but significant flaws on defence.